Dear Guests, Welcome to my blog which I treat like a creative garden where I regularly plant and change this and that be it poetry, philosophy, an Oboe Brilliance lesson, an essay of some kind, or a journal about composing. Visit every Monday for oboe coaching which is also helpful for many melodic instrumentalists. Musically yours, Kathryn

"How do you compose?" That is the most commonly asked question I hear.
This blog is a window into my creative process and philosophies as a composer and instrumentalist. At times it may contain music, photos, and poetry as well. May you enjoy, return, and benefit!

My Archives

September 2010

August 2010

July 2010

June 2010

May 2010

April 2010

March 2010

February 2010

January 2010

December 2009

November 2009

October 2009

September 2009

August 2009

July 2009

June 2009

May 2009

April 2009

March 2009

February 2009

May

6

Oboe Brilliance: Mentoring Essay # 1

Oboe Brilliance: Mentoring Essay 1
Instructor, teacher, mentor appreciation © Kathryn Potter 2009


Humans are the only creature on earth that I know of whose survival is completely dependent on having teachers, and with that, within one generation, the human race can change drastically. We need teachers.

There are three kinds of teachers:

Instructor
The job of an instructor is to clearly and accurately convey a system, tradition, and a specific way of doing something that the individual must comply and conform in order to do correctly. Martial arts are an excellent example of the important role of instructors.

Teacher
The job of a teacher is to guide the individual student into joyful discovery, learning knowledge, acquiring skill, mastering tasks, nurturing capability. There are many kinds of teachers.

Mentor
The job of a mentor is to help an individual student blossom into greater self awareness and self unfolding through patient nurturing and masterful teaching which partially incorporates both instruction and teaching. A mentor adapts teaching style to the student in order for the student to become as self realized as possible, sometimes through the focus of a specific form or medium such as music.

All of the three kinds of teachers are an art form, and positively vitally important for the health and wellness of the human race, and the planet.

Some things in life don’t require a teacher, but having one is probably better. Studying many instruments is like that. The oboe is not one of them. I tell people that an oboe student must have an oboe teacher! Putting an oboe in the hand of a child is like telling a 9 year old to do a cartwheel on the balance beam. Putting a flute in the hand of a child – for example – is like telling a 9 year old to do a cartwheel on a mat. I feel it’s advisable to make the oboe the first wind instrument of a child. If the child is too young to play the oboe, then singing and piano playing is better than playing another instrument involving the mouth. Many oboists are converters from other instruments, and that’s fine, but I feel strongly that it’s preferable to start with the oboe if that is the instrument of choice.

I have heard the term “toxic pedagogy”. This is tragic and must be avoided at all costs. Music teachers historically are known for this, and is sometimes called “old school”, which is usually meant as a means of teaching that is a degraded form of instruction as a form of cold obedience which is not what makes great musicians – in the long run – and for our world at large. In order for a human being to be a great musician, much healing must take place after receiving a toxic musical education which is possible. The purpose of Oboe Brilliance essays is to foster the strongest, healthiest, most musical student teacher relationships possible for the most brilliant musical life journey.

I owe Oboe Brilliance to the loving mentoring of Lois Wann, and Peter Hertling who raised me via the oboe.